A CIA East Asia CI Division SME (Operations/IIA/Office of East Asia Pacific) writes it "speaks exactly to what has been on my mind but what was left out of the mainline IC assessment" and "looks very good!" (p.1-2).
p.1Email — For IC Coord by 7 Oct: NIC Alternative Analysis on China/Election (7 October 2020)
Internal IC coordination email chainOct 7, 20208 pagesEMAIL_RE For IC coord by Oct 7 2020 7OCT2020 DECLASS REDACTED.pdf
Declassified by Counsel to the President Warrington 10 July 2026
Key Insights
AI-generated from the sourced claims — verify against the documents.
The Director, Election Threat Analysis and the NIO — Cyber assess that Beijing has taken some low-level, exploratory steps to denigrate the President and shape voter perceptions ahead of the election.
The Director states he has 'burned enough political capital arguing with CIA and FBI about this,' and is unsure 'why so many in the community want to close down the possibility that China might have done or be doing *something*'.
Notes that at the last COI meeting 'everyone around the table at NSA had thoughts similar' but many were reticent to express them because FBI and CIA 'seemed so adamant about their stances'.
7 sourced claims
An NSA senior described as "one of the few seniors that remained analytically focused" is noted as being on board (p.1).
p.1The Director writes he has "burned enough political capital arguing with CIA and FBI about this," and is unsure "why so many in the community want to close down the possibility that China might have done or be doing *something*" (p.3).
p.3Notes that at the last COI meeting "everyone around the table at NSA had thoughts similar" but many were reticent to express them because FBI and CIA "seemed so adamant about their stances" (p.3).
p.3They label the piece alternative analysis representing the perspective of the NIO Cyber and the Director only; they will include a large text box laying out the mainline view, and request input by COB Wednesday 7 October (p.7).
p.7The Director, Election Threat Analysis (NIC/DNI Election Threat Executive) and the NIO — Cyber announce they are publishing an alternative analysis NIC memo because they have a different take on the China/election story than what has appeared in production (p.7).
p.7Their lead, in "short non-compartmented form": they assess "that Beijing has taken some low-level, exploratory steps to denigrate the President and shape voter perceptions ahead of the election" (p.7).
p.7Page evidence
Email — For IC Coord by 7 Oct: NIC Alternative Analysis on China/Election (7 October 2020) · p.7
Page OCR text
As I’m sure many of you have gathered through coord comments, COI discussions, or other conversations, NIO Cyber and | have a somewhat different take on the China/election story than what has appeared in production so far. Rather than continue to argue about this and drive you all nuts, we are opting to publish an alternative analysis NIC memo. We think this is the best way for us to put our perspective on the record while not getting in the way of what the rest of the community wants to say. The lead, in short non-compartmented form, is that we assess that Beijing has taken some low-level, exploratory steps to denigrate the President and shape voter perceptions ahead of the election. We have really appreciated everyone’s efforts to community coord all election-related production, and in that spirit I’d like to offer you all the chance to comment on this piece. However: we are clearly labeling this as alternative analysis and highlighting that it is the perspective of NIO Cyber and myself only. Which means that we will most likely not be taking comments on board; we already know most of you disagree. But fear not. We are including a large text box laying out the mainline view. ia and f have helped us craft this, but we would very much appreciate your input on it to make sure that we’re capturing your views accurately. The intention is to show an honest analytic difference, not to set up a straw man version of the IC line to knock down. Like most of the China/election production, this piece uses . The IC Mainline Analysis text box uses Though mostly fii If you have at least and would like to coordinate on this box, please let me know. We are looking for input by COB Wednesday 7 Oct. The full piece uses a I’m still fixing some formatting issues, but can work with you to get you some version of the paper. Thank you all—we look forward to continuing conversation on this topic. Director, Election Threat Analysis National Intelligence Council/DNI Election Threat Executive Classified By: Derived From: Dated: Declassify On:
Page 7 of 8