Vulnerabilities in Electronic Voting and Ballot-Counting Systems

China: Cyber Activities Probably Prelude to Election Espionage (WIRe)

CIA World Intelligence ReviewJul 1, 20202 pagesCIA Wire Memo Summer 2020 DECLASS REDACTED.pdf

declassified by Counsel to the President Warrington 10 July 2026

Redaction map

Text (2)Redacted / blank (0)

Key Insights

AI-generated from the sourced claims — verify against the documents.

  • Chinese cyber actors have probed every US presidential election campaign since at least 2008, and as the 2020 election approached, they directly targeted a presidential campaign for the first time that cycle.

  • Since approximately 2018, Chinese cyber actors known as APT31 have targeted personal email accounts of senior US leadership, including officials in the Executive Office of the President, Congress, and the federal judiciary.

  • The IC assessed that China did not intend to covertly interfere to sway the 2020 election outcome, but the cyber espionage activity could enable such operations if Beijing decided to do so.

  • Chinese cyber actors collected US election-related information from voter databases, a polling-data company, political and nonprofit organizations, fundraisers, and advisory organizations for political campaigns.

  • APT31's use of tracking links in spear-phishing emails suggests operators are mapping target networks for follow-on approaches, possibly tasking staffers' email accounts in the Chinese military's signals-intelligence system.

11 sourced claims

China is probing the presidential campaign for opportunities to tailor collection and gather insight on US-China policy positions; Chinese cyber actors have conducted such activity in every US presidential election campaign since at least 2008 (p.1).

p.1

Since [~2018], Chinese cyber actors known in the private sector as APT31 [OCR shows "AP 3"] have targeted personal e-mail accounts of senior US leadership, including officials in the Executive Office of the President and high-ranking officials across Executive Branch organizations, Congress, and the federal judiciary (p.1).

p.1

Since 2017, a separate [REDACTED] group worked with [REDACTED] to enable more stealthy operations by identifying e-mail addresses of high-level US officials and then [REDACTED] to obtain or crack passwords for targeted [REDACTED] (p.1).

p.1

As the 2020 election approached, the IC detected Chinese state-sponsored actors targeting the former Vice President's presidential campaign, the first instance that cycle of directly targeting a US presidential campaign; China also conducted cyber espionage against other US election-related entities (p.1).

p.1

The IC assessed China did not then intend to covertly interfere to sway the election outcome, though the activity could enable such operations if Beijing decided to do so (p.1).

p.1

As of 20 May, APT31 actors sent spear-phishing e-mails with tracking links to Gmail accounts of staffers associated with a presidential campaign; on 4 June, Google announced APT31 was targeting the campaign (p.1).

p.1

Google and the FBI both briefed campaign officials shortly after discovering the activity; Google publicly stated the spear-phishing attempts were unsuccessful (p.1).

p.1

Over the prior year, Chinese cyber actors collected US election-related information from US voter databases, a polling-data company, political and nonprofit organizations, fundraisers, and advisory organizations for political campaigns (p.1).

p.1

APT31's use of tracking links suggests operators are mapping the target network for follow-on approaches, possibly tasking staffers' e-mail accounts in the Chinese military's signals-intelligence system; tracking links collect metadata (Internet activity, system information) usable to exploit accounts and identify other targets (p.1-2).

p.1

Knowledge of a target's OS and software would let actors determine whether to exploit known vulnerabilities or develop new malware; opening a tracking-link e-mail (even without clicking) confirms an active account (p.2).

p.2

Produced jointly under the auspices of the Chief of Analysis, [REDACTED], the FBI, and the NSA; Product Type: World Intelligence Review (p.2).

p.2